Logo Logo
Help
Contact
Switch Language to German

Stewart, Rush T. (2021): Uncertainty, equality, fraternity. In: Synthese, Vol. 199, No. 3-4: pp. 9603-9619

Full text not available from 'Open Access LMU'.

Abstract

Epistemic states of uncertainty play important roles in ethical and political theorizing. Theories that appeal to a veil of ignorance, for example, analyze fairness or impartiality in terms of certain states of ignorance. It is important, then, to scrutinize proposed conceptions of ignorance and explore promising alternatives in such contexts. Here, I study Lerner's probabilistic egalitarian theorem in the setting of imprecise probabilities. Lerner's theorem assumes that a social planner tasked with distributing income to individuals in a population is completely ignorant about which utility functions belong to which individuals. Lerner models this ignorance with a certain uniform probability distribution, and shows that, under certain further assumptions, income should be equally distributed. Much of the criticism of the relevance of Lerner's result centers on the representation of ignorance involved. Imprecise probabilities provide a general framework for reasoning about various forms of uncertainty including, in particular, ignorance. To what extent can Lerner's conclusion be maintained in this setting?

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item