Simpson Grade Revisited - Intraoperative Estimation of the Extent of Resection in Meningiomas Versus Postoperative Somatostatin Receptor Positron Emission Tomography/Computed Tomography and Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Ueberschaer, Moritz; Vettermann, Franziska Jill; Forbrig, Robert; Unterrainer, Marcus; Siller, Sebastian; Biczok, Anna-Maria; Thorsteinsdottir, Jun; Cyran, Clemens C.; Bartenstein, Peter; Tonn, Jörg-Christian; Albert, Nathalie Lisa and Schichor, Christian (2021): Simpson Grade Revisited - Intraoperative Estimation of the Extent of Resection in Meningiomas Versus Postoperative Somatostatin Receptor Positron Emission Tomography/Computed Tomography and Magnetic Resonance Imaging. In: Neurosurgery, Vol. 88, No. 1: pp. 140-146

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Surgeon's intraoperative estimation of meningioma extent of resection (Simpson Grade, SG) is widely used as a prognostic factor for recurrence. However, the validity of SG is still a matter of debate. In preoperative imaging, Ga-68-DOTATATE/PET-CT has been shown to detect meningioma tissue even more sensitively than magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the Simpson grading within the framework of modern postoperative imaging techniques (MRI;PET-CT). METHODS: At first, patients with WHO grade I meningioma, surgical resection, and postoperative Ga-68-DOTATATE/PET-CT within 6 mo after surgery were retrospectively analyzed. Second, an analogous prospective cohort of patients with WHO grade I meningioma was investigated by comparing SG after meningioma removal with postoperative MRI and Ga-68-DOTATATE/PET-CT within 6 mo after surgery. RESULTS: A total of 37 patients were retrospectively analyzed. In total, 5/8 patients with SG-I and II resections showed tumor remnants according to postoperative PET-CT (SG 62.5% false negative). In the prospective cohort of 52 tumors, PET-CT displayed tracer uptake in 15/37 SG-I or II resections indicating unexpected tumor remnants (SG 40.5% false negative). MRI was false negative in 7 of these 15 cases (MRI 18.9% false negative) (P=.037). Discordant results according to PET-CT were more often found in convexity (40%) and falcine (46.7%) meningiomas than in skull base meningiomas (18.2%). CONCLUSION: Intraoperative Simpson grading is at risk to underestimate tumor remnants, predominantly in grade I and II resections. Postoperative PET-CT improves detection rates compared to MRI. Prognostic impact of postoperative meningioma remnants according to PET-CT needs to be investigated prospectively.

• Item Type: Journal article
• Faculties: Medicine
• Subjects: 600 Technology > 610 Medicine and health
• ISSN: 0148-396X
• Language: English