The Long-Run Consequences of Chernobyl: Evidence on Subjective Well-Being, Mental Health and Welfare

Danzer, Alexander M. und Danzer, Natalia (10. Juni 2014): The Long-Run Consequences of Chernobyl: Evidence on Subjective Well-Being, Mental Health and Welfare. Münchener Wirtschaftswissenschaftliche Beiträge (VWL) 2014-25

Abstract

This paper assesses the long-run toll taken by a large-scale technological disaster on welfare, well-being and mental health. We estimate the causal effect of the 1986 Chernobyl catastrophe after 20 years by linking geographic variation in radioactive fallout to respondents of a nationally representative survey in Ukraine according to their place of residence in 1986. The psychological effects of this nuclear disaster are large and persistent. More affected individuals exhibit poorer subjective well-being, higher depression rates and lower subjective survival probabilities; they rely more on governmental transfers as source of subsistence. We estimate the aggregate annual welfare loss at 6–8% of Ukraine’s GDP highlighting previously ignored externalities of large-scale catastrophes.

• Dokumententyp: Paper
• Keywords: Chernobyl, nuclear catastrophe, externality, subjective well-being, mental health, depression, transfer dependency, welfare loss, natural experiment
• Fakultät: Volkswirtschaft ; Volkswirtschaft > Munich Discussion Papers in Economics
• Themengebiete: 300 Sozialwissenschaften > 330 Wirtschaft
• JEL Classification: I31, I18, D62, Q51, H12
• Sprache: Englisch

Literaturliste

Abbott, Pamela, Claire Wallace and Matthias Beck. 2006. “Chernobyl: Living with risk and uncertainty.” Health Risk & Society, 8 (2): 105–121.

Almond Douglas, Lena Edlund and Mårten Palme. 2009. “Chernobyl’s subclinical legacy: Prenatal exposure to radioactive fallout and school outcomes in Sweden.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 124 (4): 1729–1772.

Baloga, V. I, V. I. Kholosha and O. M. Evdin (eds.). 2006. 20 years after Chernobyl catastrophe. Future outlook: National report of Ukraine. Kiev: Atika.

Berger, Eva M. 2010. “The Chernobyl disaster, concern about the Environment, and life satisfaction.” Kyklos, 63 (1): 1–8.

Black, Sandra E., Aline Bütikofer, Paul J. Devereux and Kjell G. Salvanes. 2013. This Is Only a Test? Long-Run Impacts of Prenatal Exposure to Radioactive Fallout. NBER Working Paper No. 18987.

Blanchflower, David G. and Andrew J. Oswald. 2008. “Is well-being U-shaped over the life cycle?” Social Science & Medicine, 66 (8): 1733–1749.

Bromet, Evelyn J. and Johan M. Havenaar. 2007. “Psychological and perceived health effects of the Chernobyl disaster: A 20-year review.” Health Physics, 93 (5): 516–521.

Bromet, Evelyn J., Johan M. Havenaar and L.T. Guey. 2011. “A 25 Year Retrospective Review of the Psychological Consequences of the Chernobyl Accident.” Clinical Oncology, 23 (4): 297–305.

Brouwer, Werner B.F. and N.J.A. van Exel. 2005. “Expectations regarding length and health related quality of life: Some empirical findings.” Social Science & Medicine, 61 (5): 1083–1094.

IAEA. 2005. Chernobyl’s Legacy: Health, Environmental and Socio-Economic Impacts. Chernobyl Forum. Retrieved 03 May 2014. URL: http://www.iaea.org/Publications/ Booklets/ Chernobyl/chernobyl.pdf.

Clark, Andrew E., Paul Frijters and Michael A. Shields. 2008. “Relative income, happiness, and utility: An explanation for the Easterlin paradox and other puzzles.” Journal of Economic Literature, 46 (1): 95–144.

Clark, Andrew E. and Andrew J. Oswald. 2002. “A simple statistical method for measuring how life events affect happiness.” International Journal of Epidemiology, 31 (6): 1139–1144.

Danzer, Alexander M. 2013. “Benefit Generosity and the Income Effect on Labour Supply: Quasi-Experimental Evidence.” Economic Journal, 123 (571): 1059–1084.

Demidchik, Evgeny P., Anton Mrochek, Yuri Demidchik, Tatiana Vorontsova, Eugeny Cherstvoy, Jacov Kenigsberg, V. Yuri Rebeko and Akira Sugenoya. 1999. “Thyroid cancer promoted by radiation in young people of Belarus (clinical and epidemiological features).” In Thomas, G., A. Karaoglou and E.D. Williams (eds.), Radiation and Thyroid Cancer. Proceedings of the International Seminar on Radiation and Thyroid Cancer. Brussels, Luxembourg: World Scientific.

European Commission. 1998. Atlas of Caesium Deposition on Europe After the Chernobyl Accident. Edinburgh: Edinburgh Press.

European Commission. 2004. Actions against depression. Improving mental and well-being by combating the adverse health, social and economic consequences of depression. Retrieved 04 June 2014. URL: http://ec.europa.eu/health/archive/ph_determinants/ life_style/mental/docs/depression_en.pdf.

Faure, Michael G. and Göran Skogh. 1992. “Compensation for Damages Caused by Nuclear Accidents: A Convention as Insurance.” The Geneva Papers on Risk and Insurance, 17: 499–513.

Firsakova, S.K. 1993. “Effectiveness of countermeasures applied in Belarus to produce milk and meat with acceptable levels of radiocaesium after the Chernobyl accident.” The Science of the Total Environment, 137: 199-203.

Frey, Bruno S., Simon Lüchinger and Alois Stutzer. 2010. “The Life Satisfaction Approach to Environmental Valuation.” Annual Review of Resource Economics, 2:139–60.

Frijters, Paul, John P. Haisken-DeNew and Michael A. Shields. 2004. “Money Does Matter! Evidence from Increasing Real Income and Life Satisfaction in East Germany Following Reunification” American Economic Review, 94 (3): 730-740.

Gargiulo, R. Adriana and Mark A. Stokes. 2009. “Subjective well-being as an indicator for clinical depression.” Social Indicators Research, 92(3): 517-527.

Gould, Peter. 1990. Fire in the Rain: The Democratic Consequences of Chernobyl. Baltimore, MD: Johns Hopkins University Press.

Gregory, Paul R. and Janet E. Kohlhase. 1988. “The earnings of Soviet workers: Evidence from the Soviet Interview Project.” Review of Economics and Statistics, 70 (1): 23–35.

Greenpeace. 2006. The Chernobyl Catastrophe: Consequences for Human Health. Greenpeace: Amsterdam.

Gruber, Jonathan. 2010. Public Finance and Public Policy. 3rd ed. New York: Worth Publishers.

Halla, Martin and Martina Zweimüller. 2014. Parental Response to Early Human Capital Shocks: Evidence from the Chernobyl Accident. IZA Discussion paper No. 7968.

Hamermesh, Daniel S. 1985. “Expectations, Life Expectancy, and Economic Behavior.” Quarterly Journal of Economics, 100 (2): 389–408.

Havenaar, Johan M., Galina M. Rumyantzeva, Wim van den Brink, Nico W. Poelijoe, Jan van den Bout, Herman van Engeland and Maarten W. J. Koeter. 1997. “Long-term mental health effects of the Chernobyl disaster: An epidemiologic survey in two former Soviet regions.” American Journal of Psychiatry, 154 (11): 1605–1607.

Headey, B.W., J. Kelley and A.J. Wearing. 1993. “Dimensions of mental health: Life satisfaction, positive affect, anxiety, and depression.” Social Indicators Research, 29: 63–82.

Hurd, M. D. and K. McGarry. 2002. “The Predictive Validity of Subjective Probabilities of Survival.” Economic Journal, 112: 966–985

Ivanov, Victor K., Anton I. Gorski, Marat A. Maksioutov, Anatoly F. Tsyb and Anton G. Souchkevitch. 2001. “Mortality among the Chernobyl emergency workers: Estimation of radiation risks.” Health Physics, 81 (5): 514–521.

Kimball, Miles, Helen Levy, Fumio Ohtake and Yoshiro Tsutsui. 2006. “Unhappiness after Hurricane Katrina.” NBER Working Paper No. 12062.

Kunreuther, Howard and Douglas Easterling. 1990. “Are Risk-Benefit Tradeoffs Possible in Siting Hazardous Facilities?” American Economic Review, 80 (2): 252–256.

Laes, Erik, Gaston Meskens and Jeroen P. van der Sluijs. 2011. “On the contribution of external cost calculations to energy system governance: The case of a potential largescale nuclear accident.” Energy Policy, 39: 5664–5673.

Lee, T.R. 1996. Environmental stress reactions following the Chernobyl accident. in: One Decade After Chernobyl. Summing up the Consequences of the Accident. Proceedings of an International Conference, Vienna. STI/PUB/1001. IAEA: Vienna: 283-310.

Lehmann, Hartmut and Jonathan Wadsworth. 2011. “The impact of Chernobyl on health and labour market performance.” Journal of Health Economics, 30 (5): 843–857.

Lehmann, Hartmut, Alexander Muravyev and Klaus F. Zimmermann. 2012. “The Ukrainian longitudinal monitoring survey: towards a better understanding of labor markets in transition.” IZA Journal of Labor & Development, 1: 9.

Levinson, Arik. 2012. “Valuing public goods using happiness data: The case of air quality.” Journal of Public Economics, 96: 869–880.

Likhtarev I.A., G.M. Guiko, B.G. Sobolev, I.A. Kairo, N.I. Chepurnoy, G. Pröhl and K. Henrichs. 1994 “Thyroid dose assessment for the Chernigov region (Ukraine): Estimation based on 131I thyroid measurements and extrapolation of the results to districts without monitoring.” Radiation and Environmental Biophysics, 33:149-166.

Loganovsky, Konstantin, Johan M. Havenaar, Nathan L. Tintle, Lin T. Guey, Roman Kotov and Evelyn J. Bromet. 2008. “The mental health of clean-up workers 18 years after the Chernobyl accident.” Psychological Medicine, 38 (4): 481–488.

Lüchinger, Simon. 2009. “Valuing Air Quality Using the Life Satisfaction Approach.” Economic Journal 119(536): 482-515.

Lüchinger, Simon and Paul A. Raschky. 2009. “Valuing flood disasters using the life satisfaction approach.” Journal of Public Economics, 93 (3–4): 620–633.

Metcalfe, Robert, Nattavudh Powdthavee and Paul Dolan. 2011. “Destruction and distress: Using a quasi-experiment to show the effects of the September 11 attacks on mental well-being in the United Kingdom.” Economic Journal, 121 (550): F81–F103.

Mettler, F.A. Jr., H.D. Royal, J.R. Hurley et al. 1992. “Administration of stable iodine to the population around the Chernobyl nuclear power plant.” Journal of Radiological Protection, 12(3): 159-165.

Mitsikostas, Dimos D., Leonidas Mantonakis and Nikolaos Chalarakis. 2014. “Nocebo in clinical trials for depression: A meta-analysis.” Psychiatry Research, 215(1): 82-86.

Osiatynski, Jerzy. 2004. Ukrainian Chernobyl national programs enhancement. Analytical study for UNDP. Mimeo.

Oswald, Andrew J. and Nattavudh Powdthavee. 2008. “Does happiness adapt? A longitudinal study of disability with implications for economists and judges.” Journal of Public Economics, 92 (5–6): 1061–1077.

Oughton, Deborah, Ingrid Bay-Larsen and Gabriele Voigt. 2009. “Social, ethical, environmental and economic aspects of remediation.” Radioactivity in the Environment, 14: 427–451.

Powdthavee, Nattavudh and Alois Stutzer. 2014. “Economic Approaches to Understanding Change in Happiness.” In Sheldon, Kennon M. and Richard E. Lucas (eds.) Stability of Happiness, Amsterdam: Elsevier, forthcoming.

Rahu, M. 2003. “Health effects of the Chernobyl accident: fears, rumours and the truth.” European Journal of Cancer, 39: 295–299.

Rubin, G. James, Richard Amlôt, Simon Wessely and Neil Greenberg. 2012. “Anxiety, distress and anger among British nationals in Japan following the Fukushima nuclear accident.” British Journal of Psychiatry, 201:400-407.

Shigemura, Jun, Takeshi Tanigawa, Isao Saito and Soichiro Nomura. 2012. “Psychological Distress in Workers at the Fukushima Nuclear Power Plants.” The Journal of the American Medical Association, 308(7): 667-669.

Slovic, Paul. 1987. “Perception of Risk.” Science, 236 (4799): 280–285.

Sovacool, Benjamin K. 2008. “The costs of failure: A preliminary assessment of major energy accidents, 1907–2007.” Energy Policy, 36: 1802–1820.

State Statistics Committee of Ukraine. 2004. Statistical Yearbook of Ukraine 2003. Kiev, Ukraine.

Udovyk, Oleg. 2007. “Learning from Chernobyl: Past and present responses.” in C. Mothersill et al. (eds.), Multiple Stressors: A Challenge for the Future: 449–453.

United Nations. 2001. “Optimizing the international effort to study, mitigate and minimize the consequences of the Chernobyl disaster.” Report of the Secretary-General A/56/447. Retrieved 15 March 2013. URL: http://daccess-dds-ny.un.org/doc/UNDOC/ GEN/ N01/568 /09/PDF/N0156809.pdf?OpenElement

United Nations. 2002. “The human consequences of the Chernobyl nuclear accident. A strategy for recovery.” A Report Commissioned by UNDP and UNICEF with the support of UN-OCHA and WHO. Retrieved 15 March 2013. URL: http://chernobyl.undp.org/english/docs/strategy_for_recovery.pdf

UNSCEAR. 2000. “Exposures and effects of the Chernobyl accident.” Annex J of Sources and Effects of Ionizing Radiation, Volume II. Vienna: United Nations.

UNSCEAR. 2008. “Health effects due to radiation from the Chernobyl accident.” Annex D of Sources and Effects of Ionizing Radiation, Volume II. Vienna: United Nations. U.S. National Academy of Sciences. 2006. Health risks from exposure to low levels of ionizing radiation. BEIR VII Report. National Research Council, U.S. National Academy of Sciences. Washington, DC: National Academy Press.

van Praag, Bernard M. S. and Barbara E. Baarsma. 2005. “Using happiness surveys to value intangibles: The case of airport noise.” Economic Journal, 115 (500): 224–246.

Viinamäki, Heimo, Esko Kumpusalo, Markku Myllykangas, S. Salomaa, L. Kumpusalo, S. Kolmakov, I. Ilchenko, G. Zhukowsky and A. Nissinen. 1995. “The Chernobyl accident and mental well-being—A population study.” Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 91 (6): 396–401.

Wang, Philip S., Sergio Aguilar-Gaxiola, Jordi Alonso, Matthias C Angermeyer, Guilherme Borges, Evelyn J Bromet, Ronny Bruffaerts, Giovanni de Girolamo, Ron de Graaf, Oye Gureje, Josep Maria Haro, Elie G Karam, Ronald C Kessler, Viviane Kovess, Michael C Lane, Sing Lee, Daphna Levinson, Yutaka Ono, Maria Petukhova, José Posada-Villa, Soraya Seedat and J Elisabeth Wells. 2007. “Use of mental health services for anxiety, mood, and substance disorders in 17 countries in the WHO world mental health surveys.” The Lancet, 370(9590): 841-850.

WHO. 2005. Mental health: facing the challenges, building solutions. Geneva: World Health Organization.

WHO. 2006. Health effects of the Chernobyl accident and special health care programmes: Report of the UN Chernobyl Forum Health Expert Group. Geneva: World Health Organization.

WHO. 2013. Investing in Mental Health: Evidence for Action. Geneva: World Health Organization.

WHO World Mental Health Survey Consortium. 2004. “Prevalence, Severity, and Unmet Need for Treatment of Mental Disorders in the World Health Organization World Mental Health Surveys.” The Journal of the American Medical Association, 291 (21): 2581-2590.

Winkelmann, Liliana and Rainer Winkelmann. 1998. “Why are the unemployed so unhappy? Evidence from panel data.” Economica, 65 (257): 1–15.