The Political Sustainability of a Basic Income Scheme and Social Health Insurance

Kifmann, Mathias und Roeder, Kerstin (6. September 2014): The Political Sustainability of a Basic Income Scheme and Social Health Insurance. Münchener Wirtschaftswissenschaftliche Beiträge (VWL) 2014-45

Abstract

This paper studies how society votes on the payroll taxes of a basic income and a social health insurance scheme. Individuals differ along the two most important dimensions when it comes to the design of the two welfare schemes, namely, income and risk. Even though the introduction of a basic income scheme opens up the possibility for additional redistribution, it also crowds out social health insurance. We show that when both welfare schemes are open for debate, the political equilibrium is such that only the basic income scheme prevails. At the constitutional stage we determine which welfare scheme society agrees to implement behind the veil of ignorance and with a Rawlsian objective. Since social health insurance not only redistributes income from rich to poor but also from low-risk to high-risk agents, the doubly disadvantaged in society – low-income and high-risk agents – may lose out in the political process when a basic income scheme is in place. Depending on the amount of health care expenditure and the inequalities in income and risk, it may well be that a society will find it optimal to set up an institutional framework for a social health insurance scheme only.

• Dokumententyp: Paper
• Keywords: Basic Income, Social Health Insurance, Income Taxation, Political Support
• Fakultät: Volkswirtschaft ; Volkswirtschaft > Munich Discussion Papers in Economics
• Themengebiete: 300 Sozialwissenschaften > 330 Wirtschaft
• JEL Classification: D6, D7, H1, H2, H5
• Sprache: Englisch

Literaturliste

[1] Atkinson, A.B., “The Case for a Partcipation Income,”The Political Quarterly, 1996a, 67 (1), 67–70.

[2] Atkinson, A.B., Public Economics in Action: The Basic Income/Flat Tax Proposal, 1996b, Oxford University Press.

[3] Boadway, R., M. Leite-Monteiro, M. Marchand, and P. Pestieau, “Social Insurance and Redistribution with Moral Hazard and Adverse Selection,”Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 2006, 108 (2), 279–298.

[4] Casamatta, G., H. Cremer, and P. Pestieau, “Political Sustainability and the Design of Social Insurance,”Journal of Public Economics, 2000, 75 (3), 686–712.

[5] Clark, C.M., and C. Kavanagh, “Basic Income, Inequality, and Unemployment: Rethinking the Linkage between Work and Welfare,”, Journal of Economic Issues, 1996, 30 (2), 399–406.

[6] Conde Ruiz, J.I., and P. Profeta, “The Redistributive Design of Social Security Systems,” The Economic Journal, 2007, 117 (520), 2157–2169.

[7] Friedman, M., Capitalism and Freedom, 1962, Chicago University Press, Chicago.

[8] Galasso, V., “Postponing Retirement: The Political Effect of Aging,”Journal of Public Economics, 2008, 92 (10), 2157–2169.

[9] Galasso, V., and P. Profeta, “How Does Ageing Affect the Welfare State?,”European Journal of Political Economy, 2007, 23, 554–563.

[10] Kifmann, M., “Health Insurance in a Democracy: Why is It Public and Why are Premiums Income Related?,”Public Choice, 2005, 124 (3)-(4), 283–308.

[11] Marx, A., and H. Peeters, “An Unconditional Basic Income and Labor Supply: Results from a Pilot Study of Lottery Winners,”The Journal of Socio-Economics, 2008, 37, 1636– 1659.

[12] Meltzer, A.H., and S.F. Richard, “A Rational Theory of the Size of the Government,” Journal of Political Economy, 1981, 89 (5), 914–927.

[13] Mossin, J., “Aspects of Rational Insurance Purchasing,”Journal of Political Economy, 1968, 76 (4), 553–568.

[14] Nuscheler, R., and K. Roeder, “The Political Economy of Long-Term Care,”European Economic Review, 2013, 62, 154–173.

[15] Opielka, M, “The Likelihood of a Basic Income in Germany,”International Social Security, 2008, 61 (3), 73–94.

[16] Pauly, M.V., and B. Herring, “Risk Pooling and Regulation: Policy and Reality in Today’s Individual Health Insurance Market,”Health Affairs, 2007, 26, 770–779.

[17] Rawls, J., A Theory of Justice, 1971, Harvard University Press, Cambridge MA.

[18] Saltman, R.B., R. Busse, and J. Figueras, Social Health Insurance Systems in Western European Countries, 2004, Open University Press.

[19] Shepsle, K., “Institutional Arrangements and Euqilibrium in Multidimensional Voting Models,”American Journal of Political Science, 1979, 23 (1), 27–59.

[20] Tobin, J., J.A. Pechman, and P.M. Mieszkowski, “Is a Negative Income Tax Practical?,” Yale Law Journal, 1967, 77, 1–27.

[21] Van Parijs, P., “Why Surfers Should be Fed: The Liberal Case for an Unconditional Basic Income,”Philosophy & Public Affairs, 1991, 20 (2), 101–131.

[22] Van Parijs, P., “Competing Justifications of a Basic Income,”in: Introduction to Arguing for Basic Income, 1992, Ed.: P. Van Parijs, London: Verso, 3–43.

[23] Van Parijs, P., “Real Freedom for All. What (if Anything) Can Justify Capitalism?,”1995, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

[24] Van Parijs, P., “Basic Income: A Simple and Powerful Idea for the 21st Century,”Politics & Society, 2004, 32, 7-40.