Logo Logo
Help
Contact
Switch Language to German
Dewar, Neil (2019): Ramsey Equivalence. In: Erkenntnis, Vol. 84, No. 1: pp. 77-99
Full text not available from 'Open Access LMU'.

Abstract

In the literature over the Ramsey-sentence approach to structural realism, there is often debate over whether structural realists can legitimately restrict the range of the second-order quantifiers, in order to avoid the Newman problem. In this paper, I argue that even if they are allowed to, it won't help: even if the Ramsey sentence is interpreted using such restricted quantifiers, it is still an implausible candidate to capture a theory's structural content. To do so, I use the following observation: if a Ramsey sentence did encode a theory's structural content, then two theories would be structurally equivalent just in case they have logically equivalent Ramsey sentences. I then argue that this criterion for structural equivalence is implausible, even where frame or Henkin semantics are used.