Jonas, Silvia
(2020):
MATHEMATICAL AND MORAL DISAGREEMENT.
In: Philosophical Quarterly, Vol. 70, No. 279: pp. 302327

Full text not available from 'Open Access LMU'.
Abstract
The existence of fundamental moral disagreements is a central problem for moral realism and has often been contrasted with an alleged absence of disagreement in mathematics. However, mathematicians do in fact disagree on fundamental questions, for example on which settheoretic axioms are true, and some philosophers have argued that this increases the plausibility of moral visavis mathematical realism. I argue that the analogy between mathematical and moral disagreement is not as straightforward as those arguments present it. In particular, I argue that pluralist accounts of mathematics render fundamental mathematical disagreements compatible with mathematical realism in a way in which moral disagreements and moral realism are not.