A Three-Decade “Kuhnian” History of the Antebellum Puzzle: Explaining the shrinking of the US population at the onset of modern economic growth

Komlos, John (2012): A Three-Decade “Kuhnian” History of the Antebellum Puzzle: Explaining the shrinking of the US population at the onset of modern economic growth. Münchener Wirtschaftswissenschaftliche Beiträge (VWL) 2012-10

Abstract

In 1979, when anthropometric history was still in its infancy, Robert Fogel and collaborators reported that the height of the US male white population began to decline quite unexpectedly around the birth cohorts of 1830. This was quite a conundrum on account of the fact that according to conventional economic theory nutritional status was not expected to diminish at the outset of modern economic growth, i.e., at a time when incomes were growing robustly. Although many hypotheses were offered, not until 1987 was the comprehensive solution to the puzzle offered that the height decline was due primarily to a decline in food consumption: agricultural productivity did not keep pace with rapid population growth and urbanization. However, it took a third of a century for a Kuhnian paradigm shift to occur until most of the participants in the debate accepted the model elucidated by Komlos in 1987.

• Dokumententyp: Paper
• Keywords: Anthropometric history, Heights, Thomas Kuhn, Paradigm shift, USA, Antebellum Puzzle, Living Standards
• Fakultät: Volkswirtschaft ; Volkswirtschaft > Munich Discussion Papers in Economics ; Volkswirtschaft > Lehrstühle > Seminar für Wirtschaftsgeschichte
• Themengebiete: 300 Sozialwissenschaften > 330 Wirtschaft
• JEL Classification: B20, B25, N00
• Sprache: Englisch

Literaturliste

A’Hearn, B. (1998). The Antebellum Puzzle Revisited: A New Look at the Physical Stature of Union Army Recruits during the Civil War. In: Komlos, J. & Baten, J. (Eds.), The Biological Standard of Living in Comparative Perspectives, Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag, pp. 250-267.

Bodenhorn, H. (1999). A Troublesome Caste: Height and Nutrition of Antebellum Virginia’s Rural Free Blacks. The Journal of Economic History, 59, 4, pp. 972-996.

Bogin, B. (1999). Patterns of Human Growth. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 2nd ed.

Carson, S. (2009). African-American and white inequality in the nineteenth century American South: a biological comparison. Journal of Population Economics 22, 739-755.

Carson, S.A. (2011). Height of Female Americans in the 19th century and the antebellum puzzle. Economics and Human Biology 9, 2 157-164.

Cohen M.N. & Armelagos, G.J. (Eds.), Paleopathology at the Origins of Agriculture. New York Academic Press, 1984.

Costa, D.L. (1993). Height, Wealth, and Disease among the Native-Born in the Rural, Antebellum North. Social Science History, 17, 3, pp. 355-383.

Costa, D.L. & Steckel, R.H. (1995). Long-Term Trends in Health, Welfare, and Economic Growth in the United States, NBER Historical Working Paper no. 76.

Costa, D.L. & Steckel, R.H. (1997). Long-Term trends in Health, Welfare, and Economic Growth in the United States. In: Steckel, R.H. & Floud, R. (Eds.). Health and Welfare During Industrialization, pp. 47–89. Chicago: University of Chicago Press for NBER.

Craig, L.A. (2005). EH.NET Review of Timothy Cuff, _The Hidden Cost of Economic Development: The Biological Standard of Living in Antebellum Pennsylvania. http://eh.net/book_reviews/hidden-cost-economic-development-biological-standard-living-antebellum-pennsylvania accessed January 30, 2012.

Craig, L.A. & T. Weiss, 1998. Nutritional Status and Agricultural Surpluses in the Antebellum United States. In The Biological Standard of Living in Comparative Perspective, edited by John Komlos and Joerg Baten, Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag, 190–207.

Cuff, T. (1992). A Weighty Issue Revisited: New Evidence on Commercial Swine Weights and Pork Production in Mid-Nineteenth Century America. Agricultural History 66, 4, 55-74.

Cuff, T. (1993). The Body Mass Index Values of Mid-Nineteenth-Century West Point Cadets: A Theoretical Application of Waaler's Curves to a Historical Population. Historical Methods 26, 4, 171-182.

Cuff, T. (2005). The Hidden Cost of Economic Development: The Biological Standard of Living in Antebellum Pennsylvania. Aldershot, UK: Ashgate Publishing.

Floud, R., Fogel, R.W. Harris, B. and Hong, S.C. 2011. The Changing Body. Health, Nutrition, and Human Development in the Western World since 1700. Cambridge University Press.

Fogel, R.W. (1984). Nutrition and the Decline in Mortality Since l700: Some Preliminary Findings. NBER Working Paper No. l402. Cambridge, MA.

Fogel, R.W. (1986a). Nutrition and the Decline in Mortality since 1700: Some Additional Preliminary Findings. NBER Working Paper 1802.

Fogel, R.W. (1986b). Nutrition and the Decline in Mortality since 1700: Some Preliminary Findings. In: Engerman, S.L. & Gallman, R.E. (Eds.). Long term actors in American economic growth. Chicago: U. of Chicago Press, pp. 439-527.

Fogel, R.W. (1990). The Conquest of High Mortality and Hunger in Europe and America: Timing and Mechanisms. NBER Working Paper No. 16.

Fogel, R.W. (2004). The Escape from Hunger and Premature Death, 1700-2100. Europe, American, and the Third World. Cambridge University press.

Fogel, R.W. & Engerman, S.L. (1982). Guest Editors' Foreword. Social Science History, 6, 4, Trends in Nutrition, Labor, Welfare, and Labor Productivity, pp. 395-400.

Fogel, R.W., Engerman, S.L., Floud, R. Steckel, R.H., Trussell, J., Wachter, K.W., Margo, R., Sokoloff, K. & Villaflor, G. (1979). The Economic and Demographic Significance of Secular Changes in Human Stature: The U.S. 1750-1960. NBER working paper April 1979.

Fogel, R.W., Engerman, S.L., Floud, R., Steckel, R.H., Trussell, J., Wachter, K.W., Sokoloff, K., Villaflor, G., Margo, R., & Friedman, G. (1982a). Changes in American and British Stature since the Mid- Eighteenth Century: A Preliminary Report on the Usefulness of Data on Height for the Analysis of Secular Trends in Nutrition, Labor Productivity, and Labor Welfare. NBER working paper No. 890.

Fogel, R.W., Engerman, S.L., Trussell, J. (1982b). Exploring the Uses of Data on Height: The Analysis of Long-Term Trends in Nutrition, Labor Welfare, and Labor Productivity. Social Science History, 6, 4, 401-421.

Fogel, R.W., Engerman, S.L., Floud, R., Friedman, G., Margo, R.A., Sokoloff, K., Steckel, R.H., Trussell, J., Villaflor, G., & Wachter, K.W. (1983). Secular Changes in American and British Stature and Nutrition. Journal of Interdisciplinary History 14, 2, 445-81.

Gallman, R.E. (1996). Dietary Change in Antebellum America. The Journal of Economic History, 56, 1, 193-201.

Goldin, C. & Margo, R.A. (1988). The Poor at Birth: Infant Auxology and Mortality at Philadelphia’s Almshouse Hospital, 1848-1873. NBER Working Paper No. 2525.

Goldin, C. & Margo, R.A. (1989). The Poor at Birth: Birthweights and Infant Mortality at Philadelphia’s Almshouse Hospital, 1848-1873. Explorations in Economic History 26, 360-379

Goldin, C. & Margo, R.A. (1989). Wages, Prices, and Labor Markets before the Civil War. NBER Working Paper No. 3198.

Goldin, C. & Margo, R.A. (1992). Wages, Prices, and Labor Markets Before the Civil War. In Goldin, C. & Rockoff, H. (Eds.). Strategic Factors in Nineteenth Century American Economic History. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 67-104

Gould, B. (1869). Investigations in the military and anthropological statistics of American soldiers. Cambridge: Riverside Press.

Haines, M. (1998a). Health, Height, Nutrition, and Mortality: Evidence on the “Antebellum Puzzle” from Union Army Recruits for New York State and the United States. In Komlos, J. & Baten, J. (Eds.), The Biological Standard of Living in Comparative Perspective, Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag, pp. 155-180.

Haines, M. (1998b). Estimated Life Tables for the United States, 1850–1910. Historical Methods 31, 4, 149–169.

Haines, M.R., Craig, L.A., & Weiss, T. (2003). The Short and the Dead: Nutrition, Mortality, and the “Antebellum Puzzle” in the United States” The Journal of Economic History, 63, 2, 382-383.

Haines, M., Craig, L.A., Weiss, T. (2011). Did African Americans experience the ‘Antebellum Puzzle’? Evidence from the United States colored troops during the Civil War. Economics and Human Biology 9, 1, 45–55.

Komlos, J. (1985). Stature and Nutrition in the Habsburg Monarchy: the Standard of Living and Economic Development in the Eighteenth Century. American Historical Review 90, 5, pp. 1149-1161.

Komlos, J. (1987). The Height and Weight of West Point Cadets: Dietary Change in Antebellum America. The Journal of Economic History 47, 4, 897-927.

Komlos, J. (1989). Nutrition and Economic Development in the Eighteenth-Century Habsburg Monarhy: An Anthropometric History. Princeton: Princeton University Press.

Komlos, J. (1992). Toward an Anthropometric History of African-Americans: the Case of the Manumitted Slaves of Maryland. In: Goldin, C. & Rockoff, H. (Eds.). Strategic Factors in Nineteenth Century American Economic History: A Volume to Honor Robert W. Fogel. Chicago: University of Chicago Press, The National Bureau of Economic Research, Studies in Income and Wealth, 52, pp. 297-329.

Komlos, J. (1996) Anomalies in Economic History: Reflections on the 'Antebellum Puzzle'. The Journal of Economic History 56, 1, 202-214.

Komlos, J. (1998). On the Biological Standard of Living of African-Americans: the Case of the Civil War Soldiers. In Komlos, J. & Baten, J. (Eds.), The Biological Standard of Living in Comparative Perspectives, Stuttgart: Franz Steiner Verlag, pp. 236-249.

Komlos, J. (1998). Shrinking in a growing economy? The mystery of physical stature during the Industrial Revolution. The Journal of Economic History 58, 4, 779–802.

Komlos, J. & Coclanis, P. (1997). On the 'Puzzling' Antebellum Cycle of the Biological Standard of Living: the Case of Georgia. Explorations in Economic History, 34, 4, 433-59.

Kuhn, T. (1962). The Structure of Scientific Revolutions. The University of Chicago Press.

Lang, S., Sunder, M., 2003. Non-parametric regression with BayesX: a flexible estimation of trends in human physical stature in 19th century America. Economics and Human Biology 1 (1), 77–89.

Margo, R. (1994). The Price of Housing in New York City, 1830-1860. National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper Series on Historical Factors in Long Run Growth, No. 63.

Margo, R. (1996).The Rental Price of Housing in New York City, 1830-1860. The Journal of Economic History, 56, No. 3, pp. 605-625.

Margo, R. (2000). Wages and Labor Markets in the United States, 1820-2860. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Margo, R.A. & Steckel, R. (1982).The Heights of American Slaves: New Evidence on Slave Nutrition and Health. Social Science History, 6, 4, pp. 516-538.

Margo, R.A., and Steckel, R.H. 1983. Heights of Native-Born Whites during the Antebellum Period. The Journal of Economic History 43, no. 1, 167-174.

Margo, R.A. & Villaflor, G.C. (1987). The Growth of Wages in Antebellum America: New Evidence. The Journal of Economic History, 47, 4: 873-895.

Mummert, A., Esche, E., Robinson, J.R., & Armelagos, G.J. (2011). Stature and Robusticity during the Agricultural Transition: Evidence from the Bioarchaeological Record. Economics and Human Biology.

Prince, J.M. (1995). Intersection of Economics, History, and Human Biology: Secular Trends in Stature in Nineteenth-Century Sioux Indians. Human Biology 67, 3, 387-406.

Rees, R., Komlos, J., Long, N.V. & Woitek, U. (2003). Optimal Food Allocation in a Slave Economy. Journal of Population Economics 16, 21-36.

Rhode, P.W. (2002). Gallman’s Annual Output Series for the United States, 1834-1909. NBER Working Paper no. 8860.

Steckel, R. (1979). Slave Height Profiles from Coastwise Manifests." Explorations in Economic History 16, 4, 363-380.

Steckel, R.H. (2006). Health, Nutrition, and Physical Well-Being. In Historical Statistics of the United States: Millennial Edition, New York: Cambridge University Press, pp. 2-499 to 2-620.

Steckel, R.H. (2008). Biological measures of the standard of living. Journal of Economic Perspectives 22, (1), 129-152.

Steckel, R.H. (2009). Heights and human welfare: Recent developments and new directions. Explorations in Economic History 46, 1-23.

Steckel, R.H. (1983). Height and Per Capita Income. Historical Methods, 16,1, 1-7.

Steckel, R.H. (1991). Stature and Living Standards in the United States. NBER Working Paper No. 24.

Steckel, R.H. (1992). Stature and Living Standards in the United States. In Gallman. R.E. & Wallis, J.J. (Eds.), American Economic Growth and Standards of Living Before the Civil War Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 265-308.

Steckel, R.H. (1995a). Stature and the Standard of Living. Journal of Economic Literature, 33, 4, 1903-1940.

Steckel, R.H. (1995b). The Health of American Slaves: New Evidence and Analysis. Unpublished Manuscript. Department of Economics, Ohio State University.

Steckel, R.H. (1998). Strategic Ideas in the Rise of the New Anthropometric History and Their Implications for Interdisciplinary Research. The Journal of Economic History, 58, 3, pp. 803-821.

Steckel, R H. (2006). Health, Nutrition, and Physical Well-Being. In Historical Statistics of the United States: Millennial Edition, Carter, S.B., Gartner, S., Haines, M.R., Olmstead, A., Sutch, R. & Wright, G. (Eds.), pp. 2-499 to 2-620. New York: Cambridge University Press.

Steckel, R.H. (2009). Heights and human welfare: Recent developments and new directions.” Explorations in Economic History 46, 1-23.

Steckel, R.H. & Haurin, D.R. (1982). Height, Nutrition, and Mortality in Ohio, 1870-1900. Unpublished Manuscript, Ohio State University.

Steckel, R.H. & Haurin, D.R. (1994). Health and Nutrition in the American Midwest: Evidence from the Height of Ohio National Guardsmen, 1850-1910. In Komlos, J. (Ed.). Stature, Living Standards, and Economic Development, Chicago: The University of Chicago Press, pp. 117-128.

Sunder, M. (2004). The height of Tennessee convicts: another piece of the “antebellum puzzle. Economics and Human Biology 2, 75-86.

Sunder, M. (2007). Passports and economic development: an anthropometric history of the U.S. elite in the nineteenth century. Dissertation, University of Munich.

Sunder, M. (2011). Upward and onward: High-society American women eluded the antebellum puzzle. Economics and Human Biology, 9, 2, 165-171.

Sunder, M. & Woitek, U. 2005. Boom, bust, and the human body: Further evidence on the relationship between height and business cycles. Economics and Human Biology, 3, 3, 450-466.

Walsh, L.S. (1992). Consumer Behavior, Diet, and the Standard of Living in Late Colonial and Early Antebellum America, 1770-1840. In Gallman, R.E. & Wallis, J.J. (Eds.), American Economic Growth and Standards of Living Before the Civil War Chicago: University of Chicago Press, pp. 217-61.

Yoo, D. (2011). Height and Death in the Antebellum United States: A view through the lens of geographically weighted regression. Economics and Human Biology 10, 1, 43-53.

Zehetmayer, M. (2011). The postbellum continuation of the antebellum puzzle: stature in the US, 1847–1894. European Review of Economic History, 15, 2, 313-327.

Woitek, U. 2003. Height cycles in the 18th and 19th centuries. Economics and Human Biology 1, 2, 243-257.