Optimization and performance study of a proton CT system for pre-clinical small animal imaging

Meyer, Sebastian ; Bortfeldt, Jonathan ; Lämmer, Paulina; Englbrecht, Franz S.; Pinto, Marco ; Schnürle, Katrin; Würl, Matthias und Parodi, Katia (20. April 2020): Optimization and performance study of a proton CT system for pre-clinical small animal imaging. In: Physics in Medicine & Biology

Abstract

Proton computed tomography (pCT) promises to reduce or even eliminate range uncertainties inherent in the conversion of Hounsfield units into relative stopping power (RSP) for proton therapy treatment planning. This is of particular interest for proton irradiation studies in animal models due to the high precision required and uncertainties in tissue properties. We propose a dedicated single-particle tracking pCT system consisting of low material budget floating strips Micromegas detectors for tracking and a segmented time-projection-chamber with vertical Mylar absorbers, functioning as a range telescope. Based on Monte Carlo simulations of a realistic in silico beam and detector implementation, a geometrical optimization of the system components was conducted to safeguard an ideal operation close to intrinsic performance limits at 75 MeV. Moreover, the overall imaging capabilities relevant for pre-clinical proton therapy treatment planning were evaluated for a mouse model. In order to minimize extrinsic uncertainties in the estimated proton trajectories, a spacing of the two tracking planes of at least 7 cm is required in both tracking detectors. Additionally, novel in-house developed and produced aluminum-based readout electrodes promise superior performance with around 3mm-1 spatial resolution due to the reduced material budget. Concerning the range telescope, an absorber thickness within 500 µm to 750 µm was found to yield the best compromise between water-equivalent path length resolution and complexity of the detector instrumentation, still providing sub-0.5% RSP accuracy. The optimized detector configuration enables better than 2% range accuracy for proton therapy treatment planning in pre-clinical data sets. This work outlines the potential of pCT for small animal imaging. The performance of the proposed and optimized system provides superior treatment planning accuracy compared to conventional X-ray CT. Thus, pCT can play an important role in translational and pre-clinical cancer research.

• Dokumententyp: Zeitschriftenartikel
• EU Funded Grant Agreement Number: 725539
• EU-Projekte: Horizon 2020 > ERC Grants > ERC Consolidator Grant > ERC Grant 725539: SIRMIO - Small Animal Ion Irradiator for Research in Molecular Image-Guided Radio-Oncology
• Publikationsform: Submitted Version
• Keywords: proton CT; small animal imaging; pre-clinical research; proton therapy; micromegas
• Fakultät: Physik
• Themengebiete: 500 Naturwissenschaften und Mathematik > 530 Physik ; 600 Technik, Medizin, angewandte Wissenschaften > 610 Medizin und Gesundheit
• ISSN: 0031-9155, 1361-6560
• Sprache: Englisch

Literaturliste

Bashkirov V A, Schulte R W, Hurley R F, Johnson R P, Sadrozinski H F W, Zatserklyaniy A, Plautz T & Giacometti V 2016 Med. Phys. 43(2), 664–674.

Bethe H 1930 Annalen der Physik 397, 325–400.

Böhlen T, Cerutti F, Chin M, Fassò A, Ferrari A, Ortega P, Mairani A, Sala P, Smirnov G & Vlachoudis V 2014 Nuclear Data Sheets 120, 211–214.

Bopp C, Rescigno R, Rousseau M & Brasse D 2014 Physics in Medicine & Biology 59(23), N197–N210.

Bortfeld T 1997 Medical Physics 24(12), 2024–2033.

Bortfeldt J 2014 Development of Floating Strip Micromegas Detectors PhD thesis Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München.

Bortfeldt J, Bender M, Biebel O, Danger H, Flierl B, Hertenberger R, Lösel P, Moll S, Parodi K, Rinaldi I, Ruschke A & Zibell A 2016 Nuclear and Particle Physics Proceedings 273, 1173–1179.

Bortfeldt J, Biebel O, Flierl B, Hertenberger R, Klitzner F, Lösel P, Magallanes L, Müller R, Parodi K, Schlüter T, Voss B & Zibell A 2017 Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 845, 210–214.

Collins-Fekete C A, Doolan P, Dias M F, Beaulieu L & Seco J 2015 Physics in Medicine & Biology 60(13), 5071.

Dedes G, Angelis L D, Rit S, Hansen D, Belka C, Bashkirov V, Johnson R P, Coutrakon G, Schubert K E, Schulte R W, Parodi K & Landry G 2017 Physics in Medicine & Biology 62(15), 6026–6043.

Dedes G, Dickmann J, Niepel K B, Wesp P, Johnson R P, Pankuch M, Bashkirov V A, Rit S, Volz L, Schulte R W, Landry G & Parodi K 2019 Physics in Medicine & Biology .

Dickmann J, Wesp P, Rädler M, Rit S, Pankuch M, Johnson R P, Bashkirov V, Schulte R W, Parodi K, Landry G & Dedes G 2019 Physics in Medicine & Biology 64(14), 145016.

Ferrari A, Sala P, Fassò A & Ranft J 2005 FLUKA: a multi-particle transport code Technical report CERN-2005-10 (2005), INFN/TC 05/11, SLAC-R-773.

Ford E, Emery R, Huff D, Narayanan M, Schwartz J, Cao N, Meyer J, Rengan R, Zeng J, Sandison G, Laramore G & Mayr N 2017 Physics in Medicine & Biology 62(1), 43–58.

Gehrke T, Gallas R, Jäkel O & Martišı́ková M 2018 Medical Physics 45(2), 817–829.

Giomataris Y, Rebourgeard P, Robert J & Charpak G 1996 Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 376(1), 29–35.

Hudobivnik N, Schwarz F, Johnson T, Agolli L, Dedes G, Tessonnier T, Verhaegen F, Thieke C, Belka C, Sommer W H, Parodi K & Landry G 2016 Medical Physics 43(1), 495–504.

Johnson R P 2018 Reports on Progress in Physics 81(1), 016701.

Klitzner F 2019 Research and Development of Two-Dimensional Floating Strip Micromegas Detectors, PhD thesis Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München.

Kurichiyanil N, Pinto M, Rösch T, Kundel S, Wuerl M, Englbrecht F, Schreiber J & Parodi K 2019 Medical Physics 46(6), e425.

Lämmer P 2019 Studies on an ionization chamber and time projection chamber for beam position monitoring and ion transmission imaging Master’s thesis Ludwig-Maximilians-Universität München.

Magallanes L, Meyer S, Gianoli C, Kopp B, Voss B, Jäkel O, Brons S, Gordon J & Parodi K 2019 IEEE Transactions on Radiation and Plasma Medical Sciences .

Marx J N & Nygren D R 1978 Phys. Today 31N10, 46–53.

Meyer S, Kamp F, Tessonnier T, Mairani A, C. B, Carlson D J, C. G & K P 2019 Physics in Medicine & Biology 64(12), 125008.

Mori I & Machida Y 2009 Radiological physics and technology 2(1), 22.

Oancea C, Shipulin K, Mytsin G, Gao M, Pankuch M, Coutrakon G, Ordonez C, Johnson R, Bashkirov V & Schulte R 2018 Radiotherapy and Oncology 127, S470–S471.

Parodi K, Assmann W, Belka C, Bortfeldt J, Clevert D A, Dedes G, Kalunga R, Kundel S, Kurichiyanil, N, Lämmer P, Lascaud J, Lauber K, Lovatti G, Meyer S, Nitta M, Pinto M, Safari M, Schnürle K, Schreiber J, Thirolf P G, Wieser H P & Würl M 2019 Acta Oncologica 10(58), 1470.

Parodi K, Ferrari A, Sommerer F & Paganetti H 2007 Physics in Medicine & Biology 52(12), 3369.

Penfold S N, Rosenfeld A B, Schulte R W & Sadrozinksi H F W 2011 Radiation Measurements 46(12), 2069–2072.

Penfold S N, Schulte R W, Censor Y & Rosenfeld A B 2010 Medical Physics 37(11), 5887–5895.

Poludniowski G, Allinson N & Evans P 2015 The British journal of radiology 88(1053), 20150134.

Schulte R W, Bashkirov V, Loss Klock M C, Li T, Wroe A J, Evseev I, Williams D C & Satogata T 2005 Medical Physics 32(4), 1035–1046.

Schulte R W, Penfold S N, Tafas J T & Schubert K E 2008 Medical Physics 35(11), 4849–4856.

Schyns L E J R, Eekers D B P, van der Heyden B, Almeida I P, Vaniqui A & Verhaegen F 2019 The British Journal of Radiology 92(1095).

Song K H, Pidikiti R, Stojadinovic S, Speiser M, Seliounine S, Saha D & Solberg T D 2010 Physics in Medicine and Biology 55(23), 7345–7362.

Tillner F, Thute P, Bütof R, Krause M & Enghardt W 2014 Zeitschrift für Medizinische Physik 24(4), 335–351.

Verhaegen F, Dubois L, Gianolini S, Hill M A, Karger C P, Lauber K, Prise K M, Sarrut D, Thorwarth D, Vanhove C, Vojnovic B, Weersink R, Wilkens J J & Georg D 2018 Radiotherapy and Oncology 126(3), 471–478.

Verhaegen F, Granton P & Tryggestad E 2011 Physics in Medicine & Biology 56(12), R55–R83.

Volz L, Collins-Fekete C A, Piersimoni P, Johnson R, Bashkirov V, Schulte R & Seco J 2017 3.

Volz L, Piersimoni P, Johnson R P, Bashkirov V A, Schulte R W & Seco J 2019 Physics in Medicine & Biology 64(15), 15NT01.

Wang G & Jiang M 2004 Journal of X-Ray Science and Technology 12, 169–177.

Würl M, Englbrecht F, Parodi K & Hillbrand M 2016 Physics in Medicine & Biology 61(2), 958.

Yang M, Zhu X R, Park P, Titt U, Mohan R, Virshup G, Clayton J & Dong L 2012 Physics in Medicine & Biology 57(13), 4095–4115.